Brad: After thinking more about the film over the weekend my strong opinion of not liking it was waned some. I definitely didn’t hate it that’s for sure. In fact I think it was one of the best super hero movies I ever seen in terms of action and acting but it was just a very disappointing Superman movie. It was humorless and bland for such an iconic character. There was zero chemistry between Lois and Clark. I definitely commend the filmmakers for trying something new and fresh but I think if they melded the light-heartedness of the Reeve movies with the realism and 21st-century mentality of the Nolan Batman movies this would’ve been a beloved summer blockbuster.
Brian: And I think my liking it has dipped a little bit. It was entertaining, but there was too much angst and it just could have been done better.
Brad: I thought this film tackled the alien with strange powers theme and did it relatively well I think. Better than the original Reeve one which glossed over his space origin.
I would give this film a 4.5 gratuitously collapsing skyscrapers out of 10.
Brian: I’m in between a 6.5 and a 7. I guess if The Dark Knight Rises is a 3 and The Avengers is an 8, 6.75 allusions to Jesus out of 10 is good.
Brad: If it wasn’t a Superman movie but maybe a Shazam or Captain Marvel movie I’d easily give this film a 7 score.
Brian: My last nitpick, which I hope our readers can answer: Wouldn’t there be baby pee and poop all over the inside of Superman’s spacepod?
Thanks for reading our Superlong review!
Hard Ticket to Home Video 
Superman actually read this review during his flight from Krypton to Earth and still didn’t get to the last page.
LikeLike
Great review guys. Oh and I made it to the last page and missing poop inside spacepod is a disturbing mystery.
still haven’t seen it, but from reading your post I can see that the movie suffers from everything I thought it would.
LikeLike
Thanks! It wasn’t great, but entertaining enough.
LikeLike
One page is enough. Based off page 1, I’ll assume you guys were lukewarm, at best, to this movie. I pretty much agree. It was a decent movie, but the more I think about it, not a decent Superman movie.
“But did you want a slow movie? Did you want ANOTHER full-on Superman origin story?” This was my reaction, too!
LikeLike
On page 3 we hate it but on page 4 we LOVE it! Then on page 5 we’re back to lukewarm.
LikeLike
Interesting and entertaining read. Enjoyed ALL 5 pages. I too enjoyed it but didn’t love it. But I wasn’t expecting too much because I’m not huge on Supes in general. Good review.
LikeLike
Thank you! You’re very brave.
LikeLike
I get the gist but am not reading 5 pages of it, next time video this conversation 😀
LikeLike
We can’t, I slur my words way too much and Brad’s image can’t be captured on film.
LikeLike
Haha 😀
LikeLike
I think this needed to be a full on origin or stay away from that entirely. As it was, it was a mash up and spread itself too thinly. Also, I get the whole hate about everything being destroyed and him making questionable decision but he’d only just become Superman by that point. Maybe he’d not really developed his proper moral compass by that point. Or maybe it was just dodgy writing!
LikeLike
But him developing a moral compass through his old man was the point of half the movie.
LikeLike
That’s very true. It kind of felt like he was still quite immature in this film and that he’d probably grow more mature as he gets older, hence him killing Zod and being distraught about it. I think this exemplifies one of the film’s biggest issues – it doesn’t quite know what kind of film it wants to be.
LikeLike
Yeah but he was 33, not 17.
LikeLike
Again, good point. The more I think about it, the more ridiculous it was.
LikeLike
I lost my shit when Pa Kent died the tornado. What the hell!?!? You’re going to DIE and make a widow out of your wife, leaving her the burden of running the Kent farm all on her own, because you want to prove a point to Clark? What the eff is wrong with you man! Your friggen son is Superman, just let him save you!! Someone should have spoken up about this in editing. “Do we really need to have him die?” “Oh, good point, that does seem extreme and stupid, we’ll cut that scene altogether, for brevity and common sense.”
LikeLike
Not his finest choice. And couldn’t Clark have just rescued him in a normal way? “Sorry, it’s just time for me to die for no real reason” Or they could have just gotten another friggin’ dog.
LikeLike
One of the best scenes in the 78 Superman was when Clark realized that even with all his supernatural powers he could not save someone (especially someone he loved) from dying. Having Costner wave off Clark from saving him is extremely weak to the development of Superman as a hero.
LikeLike
Yeah but to be fair 78 Superman didn’t even try to restart his dad’s heart with his heat vision.
LikeLike
Wouldn’t that just incinerate a huge whole in Pa Kent’s chest?
LikeLike
You don’t know until you try! Or he could have superpunched his heart back into rhythm.
LikeLike
lol, yeah totally! They live on a farm, they probably have tons of other dogs to choose from. And the townspeople were probably like “Wtf? you can push a bus of kids out of a lake but you can’t run over to your old man and escort him to the underpass?”
LikeLike
And didn’t the dog die anyway? All in vain!
LikeLike
And They did get a new dog too.
LikeLike
And he did reveal himself to the world not long after too so his death was twice in vain!
LikeLike
The timeline on that was really unclear. It kind of seemed like Clark was around 20 maybe, so that means he wouldn’t reveal himself for 13 more years after he wandered around finding menial work for no real reason. The world wasn’t ready in the dark days of 2000 but it’s totally ready in 2013!
LikeLike
Sweet Jesus or should I say Superman you guys sure had a long talk about this one. I wish there was as much on screen chemistry between Clark and Lois as there was with Pa Kent and his dog.
LikeLike
He loved that dog more than his own life.
LikeLike
and his wife apparently lol
LikeLike
Hmmm, maybe there’s something darker going on there….
LikeLike
haha!
LikeLike
Well – it took me almost nineteen hours to read this entire thing but I did – good job boys!
P.S. I’d go back to save my dog too.
LikeLike
Come clean, your dog read it to you.
LikeLike
It’s true!! He did!! Toots is a good boy!!
(I never learned how to read : ( )
LikeLike
I would rate it a bit higher but still, a good review 🙂
LikeLike
Nice review! I enjoyed it quite a bit actually. One thing I hope they work on in the sequel is Lane’s and Clark’s relationship. Adams described their dynamic as “a strong friendship”, which I agree with. I never really saw a romantic connection between the two, which isn’t a bad thing at all, I found their friendship really sweet and charming, so when the actual romantic interaction between the two happened, it caught me a little off guard. Perhaps that’s all down to the messy script.
LikeLike
Pingback: Pacific Rim Review | Hard Ticket to Home Video
Pingback: The Wolverine Review | Hard Ticket to Home Video
Pingback: R.O.T.O.R.’S R.O.U.N.D.U.P. 8-1-2014 | Hard Ticket to Home Video
Pingback: Reel Quick: Guardians of the Galaxy | Hard Ticket to Home Video
Pingback: Guardians of the Galaxy Review | Hard Ticket to Home Video
Pingback: Reel Quick: The Amazing Spider-Man 2 | Hard Ticket to Home Video
Pingback: DAYLIGHT (2013) WHAT THE FOOP??? | Isaacs Picture Conclusions
Pingback: Reel Quick: Terminator Genisys | Hard Ticket to Home Video
Pingback: Review: Batman v. Superman: Dawn of Just Ass | Hard Ticket to Home Video
Pingback: Reel Quick: Suicide Squad | Hard Ticket to Home Video
Pingback: Happy 5th Anniversary to Our Favorite Website: Us! | Hard Ticket to Home Video
Pingback: Reel Quick: Justice League | Hard Ticket to Home Video
Pingback: Reel Quick: Captain Marvel (Additional thoughts) | Hard Ticket to Home Video